How do you make YOUR tuna salad?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
I use only fresh tuna for my tuna fish salad. I bake fresh tuna with lime & celery salt, let it cool & flake it. Then I add chopped celery, chopped red onion, toasted almonds, chopped Granny Smith apples & Hellman's real mayo. Once I started making tuna with fresh tuna, I can't eat the canned kind. But I do buy the canned for my pets, they love it.
 
Tuna, onions(preferably green onion), miracle whip, celery, relish, a little Emerils original spice mix, sea salt.
 
this thread is great because it shows how versitile tuna salad can be.

I have 2 different simple ways that I usually make it...

The classic mayo based with chopped celery and I usually add dill which is something from my dad

the other way is with olive oil and a touch of vinegar garlic basil oregano and some chopped pepper.

I also make tuna-pasta salad failry often in the sumer to take to work for lunch. For this I dont have any set way just play around with whatever is on hand
 
^^
I'm with that guy.

I like to just do tuna, olive oil, little vinegar, chopped fresh whatever herbs I have, S&P, maybe a few capers, squeeze of lemon.

Throw that in some flatbread with some salty-sweet (shoyu/sugar) julienned veggies (carrot, celery, cucumber) and enjoy. Mmm Mmm Mmm.
 
And don't eat canned tuna more than 3 times a week... constantly.
Mercury. (so I've heard).

I avoid BumbleBee brand canned tunafish. Something about that company.
My gut worked overtime digesting that brand. Maybe a one time fluke.

Chopped celery of course. I go lightly on adding chopped green onions, that taste shows up quickly.
Same with a few dices of green bell pepper.

Yes, a very little olive oil if you use water based tuna. Too much and you taste the olive oil.

I like slicing in a hardboiled egg, makes it a meal, otherwise it's too light for a meal.

Alfalfa sprouts and thinly sliced tomato, lettuce added to the sandwhich.
I put the finished sandwhich in a toaster oven and lightly toast.

Bread and butter chips on the side, potato chips.
 
Last edited:
Well, it depends if I want a cold tuna sandwich or a hot one. For cold, I go through my veggie bin and see what I have. I like a lot of crunch in my sandwich. Dill pickles run through the fp to make relish, grated carrots, green onions chopped fine, celery, radishes chopped, chopped water chestnuts, Miracle Whip, s&p, a bed of lettuce on my whole grain bread and a deli slice of Swiss cheese on top, always open-faced.

Now for hot tuna bunsteads, tuna, hb eggs, dill pickle relish, finely chopped green onions, celery, grated sharp cheddar cheese, Miracle Whip, s&p. Put this in a good bun, wrap it in foil and put it in a 350 oven for 30 minutes until it's hot and the cheese is melted.

As for tuna, I prefer water packed but not Albacore. It's too dry and dense for a good, juicy tuna sandwich in my humble opinion.
 
Back
Top Bottom