I HATE BOTH, I HAD GI JOES AS A KID AND WAS THE YOUNGEST. MY SISTERS KEPT TAKING THEM FOR BOYFRIENDS FOR THEIR BARBIES. THOUGH COME TO THINK ABOUT IT, I DO LOVE MY "BARBIE" MORE THAN WORDS CAN SAY ! DON'T CALL HER THAT THOUGH, SHE JUST LIKES HER NAME (BARBARA) YOU NEVER HEARD IT FROM ME ! So BARBARA WINS ! with maidrite ? I am not sure I would go that far !